Producing and checking a counterexample
Key skillsUse technology to produce examples or counterexamples for a claim.
Build the idea
Technology is useful for finding examples and counterexamples, especially through graphs, tables and parameter experiments. A single valid counterexample defeats a universal claim, but repeated successful tests do not prove it. Show the exact input and mathematical evidence, then explain clearly which claim is refuted and which broader conclusion still needs a proof.
Try the sample task
Use a symbolic derivative, table and graph to refute the claim “Every stationary point is a local maximum.” Use f(x)=x³.
The full worksheet includes the worked solution and remaining task set.
What this activity covers
Focused tool-neutral investigation using a calculus model and selected sampling tasks. Students must execute and record their own tool results; expected values here are derived mathematically. The activity does not exhaust every technology function in the outcome.