Foundation to VCE • Explore the maths library • Try a free sample
Year 10 · Statistics

Teach evaluating statistical claims.

Check whether data, displays and sampling support a public claim.

View worksheets & preview

Aspire to Power Learning · https://resources.aspiretopowerlearning.com.au/home-learning/topics/year-10-evaluating-statistical-claims/

Check the starting point

  • Distinguish percentages from percentage-point differences
  • Check the population behind a count

Show the idea

Rates change the comparison

Town A has 40 cases in 4000 people and Town B has 30 in 1500. Rates are 10 and 20 per 1000 respectively, so lower count does not mean lower rate.
Select the diagram to view it at full size.

Town A has 40 cases in 4000 people and Town B has 30 in 1500. Rates are 10 and 20 per 1000 respectively, so lower count does not mean lower rate.

Work through an example

Rates change the comparison — explain the representation.

  1. Town A has 40 cases in 4000 people and Town B has 30 in 1500. Rates are 10 and 20 per 1000 respectively, so lower count does not mean lower rate.
  2. Connect the labels to the calculation or rule. An arithmetically correct percentage can still support an unjustified conclusion.

Answer: Town A has 40 cases in 4000 people and Town B has 30 in 1500. Rates are 10 and 20 per 1000 respectively, so lower count does not mean lower rate.

Teach in small steps

  1. Begin with a short oral check: ask your child to distinguish percentages from percentage-point differences. Then check that they can check the population behind a count. Revisit either skill before adding a new procedure.
  2. Explore “Rates change the comparison” together. Town A has 40 cases in 4000 people and Town B has 30 in 1500. Rates are 10 and 20 per 1000 respectively, so lower count does not mean lower rate. Ask your child to point to the quantities or features used at each step.
  3. Model the example: A headline says 80% support a proposal after 40 of 50 voluntary website voters support it. Pause before each step and invite a prediction. 80% correctly describes those respondents. A voluntary website poll may not represent the wider population.
  4. Work together on the first new practice question: A rate rises from 20% to 25%. Give the percentage-point rise and the relative percentage rise. Have your child attempt the remaining learn questions with less help, then move to apply. Use the checkpoint on a later attempt to see which ideas are retained.

Ask and listen

  • A poll reports 48 supporters among 80 respondents. State the sample percentage.
  • A headline claims a new teaching app caused better results based on volunteers who chose it. Name one design detail needed before accepting causation.

Adapt the practice

More support

Return to “Rates change the comparison” and explain one label or step at a time. An arithmetically correct percentage can still support an unjustified conclusion. Let your child show a calculation, drawing or spoken explanation before requiring a polished written answer.

More challenge

Try this application after the core method is secure: A business advertises average savings using only customers with positive savings. What additional data should be included for a claim about all customers? Then ask which assumption or input could be changed and what would need to be recalculated.

Look for understanding

  • The learner can complete and explain this checkpoint task: A graph starts its vertical axis at 49 for values 50 and 52. Find the actual percentage increase and explain the visual concern.
  • The learner can address the reasoning or error-checking question: A headline claims a new teaching app caused better results based on volunteers who chose it. Name one design detail needed before accepting causation. Accept a correct alternative method, but ask for the mathematical reason.

Choose the next step

If both checks can be explained without prompting, continue to Conditional probability and independence. If a method is still uncertain, repeat the visual example with fresh numbers before progressing.

Put the idea into practice

The matching topic collection includes learn-and-practise, application and checkpoint PDFs with worked answers. Download the free preview to see representative pages.

Explore this topic’s worksheets